BuyingFirst-Time Home BuyersHow Much House Can I AffordDown PaymentsCredit Scores & MortgagesFHA LoansVA LoansUSDA LoansJumbo LoansEscrow ExplainedClosing CostsHome InspectionsAppraisals
SellingPricing Your HomeHome StagingPre-Listing RepairsMarketing Your ListingNegotiating OffersSeller DisclosuresThe Closing ProcessCapital Gains on a Home SaleSelling Cost Calculator
InvestingRental Property InvestingThe BRRRR MethodHouse FlippingShort-Term RentalsMultifamilySelf StorageMobile Home ParksREITsReal Estate Syndications1031 ExchangesDSCR CalculatorCap Rate Calculator
CalculatorsMortgage CalculatorRefinance CalculatorAmortization ScheduleAffordability CalculatorLoan ComparisonCash Flow CalculatorCap Rate CalculatorNOI CalculatorDSCR CalculatorROI CalculatorClosing Cost CalculatorProperty Tax CalculatorHouse Flip CalculatorRent vs BuyAll 16 calculators
ResourcesLearning CenterReal Estate GlossaryBlogDownloads & ChecklistsState GuidesCity GuidesHousing Market DataEconomic ReportsProperty ManagementCommercial Real EstateInsuranceLegal ResourcesHome ImprovementMoving
Property ManagementCommercialMarket TrendsLearning CenterState GuidesCity GuidesGlossaryAbout
Blog

Why Insurance Became the Affordability Story

Premium increases have overtaken taxes as the fastest-growing line in many housing budgets.

A cost line that used to be background noise

For decades homeowners insurance was a rounding error in a monthly payment. In several coastal and wildfire-exposed states it has become the fastest-growing component, in some cases exceeding property tax.

What changed

Reinsurance pricing, construction cost inflation raising rebuild values, and a rising frequency of severe convective storm losses have all pushed premiums higher. Some carriers reduced writing in specific states, thinning competition and pushing owners into surplus lines or state-backed insurers of last resort.

What owners can do

Verify your dwelling coverage reflects rebuild cost rather than an inflated automatic increase. Understand your wind, hail, and hurricane percentage deductibles. Invest in mitigation features carriers credit — roof upgrades, opening protection, and defensible space. And shop at every renewal rather than accepting the rollover. See homeowners insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Will shopping actually help?

Often. Carrier appetite varies substantially by geography and roof age. An independent agent with multiple appointments is the most efficient route.

Does raising my deductible make sense?

Frequently, if you hold reserves to cover it. The premium savings on a higher all-peril deductible can be substantial.

Sara Pruitt

Editor, Tax & Legal · CPA

Sara is a CPA who spent a decade in real estate tax practice advising syndicators, flippers, and long-term landlords. She translates the Internal Revenue Code into English.

More from Sara